Trapped in What-Ifs: Does Regret Prove Free Will or Just Trick Us Into Believing It?

Photo by taylor on Unsplash

Regret. That nasty little parasite chewing through your brain at 2 AM.

It’s that terrible movie you keep replaying, but somehow, you’re the director, the actor, and the sucker buying tickets to the same bad show.

And yet—why do we feel it so deeply?

If free will is just a smoke-and-mirrors act, why does regret burn like hellfire? Let’s crack this open.

1. The Brain Is a Glitchy Hard Drive

Your brain isn’t some divine supercomputer. It’s a tired old jukebox, spitting out warped records, playing songs that were never recorded quite right. It files memories away, but not like a librarian—more like a drunk tossing papers into the wind.

Each time you recall something, it’s edited, rewritten, smeared with the fingerprints of who you are now, not who you were then.

The past isn’t a museum; it’s a dimly lit bar where the stories shift depending on who’s telling them.

So when regret taps you on the shoulder, whispering about what should’ve been, ask yourself—are you mourning what happened?

Or just the latest version your mind decided to play?

2. Regret Is Just Learning with a Hangover

Your brain is a prediction machine, but not a perfect one. It stumbles through time, stitching together lessons from the past, hoping they’ll hold up in the future.

Regret isn’t just a warning—it’s memory’s way of rewriting the past with ink that stains the future.

Touch fire once, and your hand learns faster than your heart. Pain isn’t just a teacher—it’s a sculptor, carving caution into your bones.

Free will? That’s just the space between impulse and obedience, and most people don’t live there for long.

3. The Illusion of Choice Is Addictive

Ever walked into a store and stood there, paralyzed by a hundred brands of peanut butter?

Your regret works the same way. You think you had infinite options, but really, your decision was shaped by past experiences, your gut bacteria, and whatever song was playing on the radio.

4. The Neuroscientist’s Party Pooper Moment

Neuroscientists have poked around in the brain and found that decisions are made before we even know we’re making them.

By the time we feel the weight of a choice, the gears have already turned, the switch already flipped.

Free will might just be the mind’s way of keeping us from realizing we’re passengers, not drivers.

Regret, then, is nothing more than a well-dressed afterthought. A polished monologue delivered long after the play has ended, meant to convince us we had control all along.

But maybe we’re just reciting lines, pretending the ink isn’t already dry.

5. Evolution Screwed Us Again

Regret probably helped our ancestors not get eaten by tigers or exiled from the tribe.

In modern life, though? It just makes you stare at old text messages, wondering why you sent that ‘u up?’ at 3 AM.

6. Free Will vs. Free Won’t

Maybe we don’t have free will, but we have ‘free won’t.’ The ability to pause and say, ‘Nah, let’s not ruin our life today.’

But even that could be another trick of the mind—a programmed hesitation built into the machine.

7. The Memory Trap

Memory is a terrible narrator. It edits scenes, cuts dialogue, and makes you believe things were different than they really were. You regret things based on memories that may not even be true. So what are you actually regretting?

8. The Anxiety-Driven Loop

Regret loops aren’t about logic. They’re anxiety’s way of passing the time. Your brain keeps gnawing on old mistakes like a dog on a chewed-up tennis ball. Does that sound like free will? Or just bad programming?

9. Determinism Is a Buzzkill

If everything was already set in motion from the Big Bang (personally don’t believe in it) onward, then every choice was never really a choice.

You were always going to pick the wrong major, text the wrong person, eat that gas station sushi. So regret is just a cruel joke.

10. Maybe Free Will Is Just an Excuse

Think about it. Free will is a convenient story we tell ourselves.

If we really accepted that we had no control, we’d have to let go of blame, of shame, of the idea that we could’ve done better.

And honestly? We love beating ourselves up too much to do that.

Summary Table: The Great Regret Debate

PointExplanation
1. Glitchy BrainYour memory is a mess; your regret is based on lies.
2. Regret = LearningPain is a good teacher, but that doesn’t mean you had a choice.
3. Illusion of ChoiceYou think you could’ve picked differently, but you couldn’t.
4. Neuroscience Says NopeDecisions happen before you’re aware of them.
5. Evolution Messed Us UpRegret was useful, now it just makes us sad.
6. Free Won’tMaybe you can say no, but can you really?
7. Memory LiesYou regret things based on false memories.
8. Anxiety’s PlaythingRegret is just brain noise, not proof of agency.
9. Determinism Ruins the FunEverything was set in stone from the start.
10. Free Will = ComfortWe cling to it because the alternative is too scary.

Final Words

Regret, you see, is a tricky little bastard. It crawls up your spine like an old cat you kicked once, now showing up at your door in the dead of night, meowing like it’s been starving for affection.

And it’s not so much the pain of it—it’s the nagging what-if.

The bastard gets inside your head, makes you wonder, “Could I have done that differently?”

It pulls you into this spiraling mess of self-doubt, like you’re missing some magic trick that would’ve turned your shitty hand into a winning one.

It seems like proof of free will, doesn’t it? Like if I regret what I did, it must mean I had a choice.

That’s what they tell you, right? “You could’ve chosen differently. You had a choice. Don’t you see that?”

But then, you pull back the curtain and—surprise, surprise—the machinery behind it all doesn’t look so free.

I regret smoking that damn cigarette, but did I really have a choice?

Was it just another cog in a machine, another little piece of programming? It could be that regret is built right into the system.

Maybe it’s the universe’s little way of reminding you that you’re not really in control.

The fucker, it knows you’ll wonder. It knows you’ll churn over it like a dog chewing on a bone, and maybe that’s its purpose.

To keep you guessing, keep you trapped in that loop of “What if?”

It’s like those blinking lights on your dashboard—the car is still going forward, whether you fix it or not.

You think you could fix it. You think you should. But in the end, all you can do is either keep driving or stop and stare at the damn thing.

Regret might be nothing more than a glitch, a reminder that you’re just a piece in this grand mess of things, and no matter how much you want to yank the wheel in some other direction, you can’t.

Maybe that’s the trick.

The secret they don’t want you to know—that the more you try to figure out what you could’ve done, the more you miss what’s actually happening right in front of you.

Like that girl I met once, all black hair and red lipstick, pulling me in like a goddamn siren.

I spent years hating myself for not kissing her that night. I still regret it.

I still feel that pull in my gut like I let something good slip through my fingers.

But who knows? What if I had kissed her? What if I’d said something else, walked away from that moment, or stood my ground?

Would things have been different? Maybe. Maybe not.

But the fact is, I’ll never know, and I have no way of proving that my choices, in that moment, mattered.

What if the regret itself is part of the plan, some sick cosmic joke that makes us think we’re the ones driving this car?

So, here’s what I’ve come to: regret doesn’t mean shit. It neither proves nor denies free will.

It doesn’t matter whether I was free to choose or stuck in some predetermined loop.

It’s all the same in the end.

You live, you make decisions, and you make mistakes.

And you regret those mistakes, sure, but eventually, you stop wasting time with it.

Because there’s nothing else to do but live and die. The rest of it? Just noise.

So fuck it. You’ve made your bed, now lie in it.

Comments

Leave a Reply