I’m not sure what you expected when you clicked on this, but if you thought you were getting some sugar-coated analysis of Italo Calvino’s The Cloven Viscount, you’re in for a rude awakening.
This isn’t some fancy academic review or a highfalutin piece of pseudo-intellectual garbage. No, this is about the truth – the raw, uncomfortable truth that Calvino somehow managed to put into a book about a guy who gets blown in half by a cannonball.
You heard me right. Blown in half. A nobleman, cut clean down the middle. And one half of him is good, the other half is pure evil.
It’s like watching the world split in two and you realize that’s what we’ve all been doing to ourselves for centuries.
Let’s get something straight here: Calvino wasn’t some average schmuck trying to make a buck.
He was the kind of writer who threw your head against the wall and made you realize it was you doing the hitting, not him.
Born in 1923, the man saw the worst of humanity—World War II, fascism, poverty, all that junk—and he decided, in his own way, to tear apart the very fabric of society with his pen.
The Cloven Viscount (first published in 1952) is a small book, but it packs more existential weight than most of the overhyped tomes you’ve got sitting on your shelf.
A Quick Snapshot of the Plot
Alright, let’s go over the basics of this weird thing before we dive into the lessons. The plot’s simple on paper. Viscount Medardo, a nobleman, gets hit by a cannonball during a battle.
He’s cut down the middle. Half of him is this righteous, compassionate guy, doing what he can to right the wrongs of the world.
The other half is a sadistic bastard, a man who would do anything—kill, steal, lie—to get what he wants.
The two halves spend the rest of the book fighting it out for control, as they both try to reclaim Medardo’s land and legacy.
One wants peace. The other wants war. One offers kindness. The other offers terror.
But the real story isn’t in the action, it’s in the quiet chaos. The conflict inside the man, the mess of human nature, the weirdly comical tragedy of it all.
Calvino doesn’t just give you the typical good guy and bad guy. He serves you two halves of the same thing. And in the process, he shows us that maybe we’re all split in some way or another.
5 Lessons from The Cloven Viscount on the Dual Nature of Humanity
Ok. Here we go:
1. Good and Evil Are Just Labels – They Don’t Mean Shit
You think Medardo’s halves are just some neat little representation of good vs. evil?
You’re wrong. The half that’s supposed to be the good guy—he’s no saint. He’s still a nobleman, a man with wealth, power, and a sense of superiority that can’t help but seep through his “righteous” actions.
Sure, he’s kind and moral, but he’s also doing it from a position of privilege. He’s not exactly going to get his hands dirty for the greater good.
On the flip side, the bad half of Medardo? Yeah, he’s cruel. He’s got an ego the size of a castle. He’s ruthless. But he’s also a product of the system he was born into, a man shaped by war and the desire to reclaim what’s been lost. Is he purely evil?
No. He’s just as human as the “good” half.
Calvino is slapping you across the face with a simple truth: good and evil don’t really exist in pure forms.
They’re constructs, just like society’s idea of who’s worthy and who’s not. You look at the Viscount, and you realize: Maybe we’re all a little bit of both. That’s humanity. It’s not neat. It’s not easy. It’s a goddamn mess.
| Character Half | Traits | Motivations |
|---|---|---|
| Good Medardo | Compassionate, but inherently flawed | Wants peace, but can’t escape his privilege |
| Evil Medardo | Cruel, vindictive, but shaped by loss | Seeks power, but can’t escape his pain |
The truth is, we’ve all got a little bit of both inside of us. But society doesn’t like that. It wants us to choose a side. Well, tough luck. We’re all Medardo.
2. Identity Is a Battlefield – Don’t Expect Any Easy Answers
Medardo doesn’t just have to fight his evil half. He has to fight his own identity. Imagine that. A man divided in two, both halves trying to claim the same life.
The fight for identity is brutal, and it’s not one you win. You don’t just get to choose who you are. You’re stuck with all of it—the good, the bad, the ugly.
You may walk around thinking you’re this perfect person who only does right by the world, but deep down, you know that you’ve got that dark side lurking. We all do. And sometimes it takes something catastrophic—like getting blown in half—to make us see it.
Medardo doesn’t get “fixed.” He doesn’t find some magical cure for his divided self. Instead, he learns to live with it.
The tragedy here isn’t that he’s split; the tragedy is that none of us get the luxury of a clean break. We don’t get a reset button. We just learn to live with the parts of ourselves that we wish would disappear.
In the end, Medardo’s journey isn’t about becoming whole again. It’s about accepting that maybe being whole isn’t possible.
3. Society Can’t Handle the Truth of Our Split Selves
Medardo’s world, like ours, is built on easy categories. You’re either the hero or the villain. The good guy or the bad guy. Society can’t handle complexity. It can’t deal with someone who doesn’t fit neatly into one box.
So what happens? People pick sides. They choose to support one half of the Viscount, as if it’s an easy decision. But life isn’t easy, and neither is identity.
Society loves a good narrative. It loves to label people and shove them into little boxes. But when someone like Medardo comes along—someone who is both hero and villain—it makes the whole structure of society fall apart. Because no one knows what to do with someone who doesn’t fit the script.
And that’s what makes Calvino’s work so damn important. He’s showing us how fragile our systems really are. Society can’t handle the complexity of humanity. And yet, that’s exactly what makes us human.
4. Heroism and Villainy Are Two Sides of the Same Coin
We all love our heroes, but they’ve always got a bit of villain in them. The “good” half of Medardo may be doing the right thing, but he’s also a nobleman, a man entrenched in the same systems that create the evil half.
He’s got blood on his hands too, just a different shade. And the “evil” half of Medardo? Sure, he’s a power-hungry jerk, but he’s also the result of trauma and loss. He’s not born bad. He’s made that way by the world he’s living in.
We romanticize heroes and villains, but the truth is, both are just reactions to the same system. Both are born of the same human flaws.
And maybe that’s what Calvino’s trying to tell us: heroism and villainy aren’t so different. They’re just roles we play in the same ugly story.
5. You Don’t Fix a Broken Thing – You Live With It
In the end, Medardo doesn’t get “cured.” He doesn’t magically become whole again. Instead, he learns to live with his fractured self. And that’s the most brutal truth of all. We think healing is about fixing things, but sometimes it’s just about learning to accept the cracks and work with them.
Medardo’s story isn’t about redemption. It’s about the slow, painful process of accepting that maybe you don’t need to be fixed.
Maybe you just need to exist with the mess and still try to do something worthwhile with your life.
Conclusion
The Cloven Viscount isn’t just some quirky little postmodern fable. It’s a gut punch to the way we see ourselves and the world.
Calvino is asking us to face the uncomfortable truth: we’re all split in some way. We’re all walking around with the good and the bad, the light and the dark, fighting for control over who we are.
And that’s okay. Because the alternative – pretending we’re whole, pretending we’re perfect – is far more dangerous.
In the end, it’s not about patching up the broken parts of ourselves like some half-hearted repair job. It’s about learning to live with those fractures, embracing the chaos of who we’ve become.
Because if you can do that—if you can stand in the middle of your own personal battlefield and still keep moving forward—then, and only then, have you truly discovered what it means to be human.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.