Moral Luck: You Did Everything Right, But Lady Luck Still Kicked Your Ass

Photo by Jarosław Kwoczała on Unsplash

You’ve heard it a thousand times. “Do the right thing. Make good decisions. Live your life well, and you’ll be rewarded.”

Well, let me tell you something—life’s a twisted game where, no matter how much you try to follow the rules, Lady Luck can still kick you in the teeth.

Moral luck. It’s this nasty little trick that life plays on you. The universe rolls the dice, and whether you win or lose, well, that’s not always up to you.

Sometimes, it’s just plain cruel.

Let me walk you through this, and by the end of it, we’ll see if there’s any meaning left to hold on to.

But don’t get your hopes up.

The Problem with Moral Luck

Imagine you’ve worked your ass off. You’ve studied the philosophy of free will, you’ve been to the endless library of existentialism, and you’ve carefully constructed a life based on morality.

You’re solid. You’ve made the right choices—helping others, never stealing, never getting caught in the chaos. You’re trying to follow the script.

But, one day, while you’re walking home with a feeling of mild satisfaction in your gut, something happens. Maybe you’re in the wrong place at the wrong time, and the bank down the street gets robbed.

You’re in the wrong position to be a witness. Now, the cops think you’re involved, and bam, your life goes to hell. You’re innocent, but the world doesn’t care. This, my friend, is moral luck. And it’s the damn punchline of this cosmic joke we’re all stuck in.

It’s like something out of Kafka’s The Trial—a perfect allegory for how life throws you into a mess, and no matter how good you try to be, the forces around you will turn on you without warning.

The whole system, the whole structure of doing things right, feels like a setup.

Thomas Nagel | By Nagelt – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0

Let’s Define Moral Luck

The term “moral luck” was coined by philosopher Thomas Nagel.

He’s one of the few who’s willing to say out loud what everyone else thinks in their quietest, darkest moments: that life is unfair, and sometimes you get punished for things you didn’t even have control over.

In short, it’s the idea that the morality of your actions can depend on factors beyond your control—things like chance, the environment you were born into, or even random events.

This idea bugs the hell out of people who believe in pure free will.

They want to think that you’re responsible for every damn choice you make. But if that were true, then why the hell does a person who works their ass off at a job, does everything right, end up dead in some pointless war they had no say in?

Hell, why does someone who’s born in a shitty neighborhood end up with the kind of future that makes you want to puke? These people didn’t ask for that fate.

The worst part is, we can’t escape it.

You can sit there and philosophize all you want about destiny, morality, and free will, but the universe doesn’t give a damn. It’s not about what you deserve—it’s about what you get.

Table 1: Examples of Moral Luck

SituationGood Moral LuckBad Moral Luck
CareerYou start a business and hit it big, all thanks to timing and your hard work.You start a business, but a global recession hits and you’re wiped out, despite your efforts.
CrimeYou avoid a life of crime, and things go well for you.You get arrested for a crime you didn’t commit, and your life is ruined.
HealthYou’re in great shape because you’ve worked hard and kept your body in check.You get cancer out of nowhere, and you’ve lived a perfect lifestyle.

We can sit here all day arguing about free will and fate, but at the end of it, life always finds a way to screw you over.

We’re all just playing catch-up with some cosmic dice roll. You don’t control the universe’s whims.

Dark Humor: Embracing the Absurdity

Don’t get me wrong—if you want to stare into the abyss and laugh, there’s something strangely satisfying about it.

Life’s absurd, and if you’ve been reading enough philosophy, you start to realize that’s the punchline.

It’s like Nietzsche saying, “He who fights with monsters should be careful lest he thereby become a monster.”

The more you struggle to make sense of this mess, the more you get caught in it.

Moral luck is one of those cruel jokes that mocks our whole concept of justice.

There’s a line from Fight Club that says, “It’s only after we’ve lost everything that we’re free to do anything.”

Isn’t that the truth? You live your life, you make the right choices, and one day, just when you think things are going well, you get hit by a goddamn truck.

Maybe this is what Kafka was getting at. Maybe this is what Camus saw when he looked at the world and said, “The only real philosophical question is whether to commit suicide or not.” It’s all absurd.

But here we are—stuck with it.

Explaining It to a Kid (Or an Apprentice)

Alright, kid, let’s make this simple, not because I think you’re dumb but because life’s messy enough without adding extra frills.

Picture this: life’s a game. A big, stupid game where you’re busting your ass doing everything by the book. You study until your eyeballs hurt, make all the smart choices, even go out of your way to help the little guy.

You’re the poster child for “doing things right.” You think you’ve got it figured out, maybe even cracked the code.

And then—WHAM!—life smacks you like a bar door swung too hard.

Why? Hell if I know. Maybe the game’s rules changed while you were busy being a saint.

Maybe some other idiot’s screw-up sent the whole house of cards tumbling onto your head.

That’s moral luck—the universe’s way of saying, “Surprise, sucker!”

It’s like some cosmic bartender serving you a shot of bad whiskey when you didn’t even order one. You didn’t earn it. You didn’t ask for it. But there it is, burning its way down your throat anyway.

You could be the kindest, most upstanding human to ever walk this rock, and life can still flatten you like a bug on a windshield.

Being good doesn’t always shield you. Sometimes, it’s like wearing a raincoat in a flood—useless as hell.

Life doesn’t care if you’re the hero in your story. It’s too busy doing its own thing—changing rules, throwing curveballs, and kicking people when they least expect it.

But here’s the thing, and it’s the part that makes this whole thing worth chewing on: you still get to decide what you do next.

You can curse the game, flip the table, or roll the dice again. You can keep playing, even when it feels rigged. That’s the beauty and the curse of it. You’re stuck in the chaos, but you’re not entirely powerless.

So, kid, when life sucker-punches you—and it will—you’ve got two choices: sit there and cry about it, or stand up, wipe the blood off your lip, and throw another punch.

You’re not gonna win every round, but damn it, you’re still in the ring. And that’s gotta count for something..

Data: People and Ideas Opposing Moral Luck

There are those who reject the whole concept of moral luck.

Kant, for example, argued that morality is about intention, not the outcome.

If you do something with the right intentions, even if things go wrong, you are still morally good. This kind of thinking can be found in The Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals.

According to Kant, it’s your responsibility to do the right thing, no matter the consequences.

Then there’s the idea of pure free will.

Folks like Jean-Paul Sartre embraced this, saying we’re all responsible for our actions, regardless of circumstances.

You have the power to define yourself and your actions. The world doesn’t dictate who you are—your choices do.

Yeah, it sounds great in theory, but let’s be honest—it’s a tough pill to swallow when life decides to throw a brick at your head.

In pop culture, characters like The Joker in The Dark Knight embody the rejection of order and fairness.

He’s chaos incarnate, showing that life isn’t about fairness—it’s about survival, making it up as you go.

Table 2: Opposing Views on Moral Luck

Thinker/WorkBelief
KantMorality is based on intent, not outcomes.
Jean-Paul SartreWe create our own morality through free will.
The Joker (The Dark Knight)Life is chaos, and fairness is a lie.
Albert CamusLife is absurd, and meaning is something we create.

Time for The Curtains

So what’s the takeaway from all this?

Well, if you’re hoping for some grand solution to the absurdity of moral luck, you’re probably not going to find it.

In fact, life will just keep playing you for a fool, no matter how hard you try.

You’ve got to make a choice. Do you sit there and wallow in nihilism, letting the chaos swallow you whole?

Or do you stand up and say, “I don’t know what the hell this all means, but I’m going to keep going”?

The latter’s hard as hell, but maybe that’s all we’ve got.

So, yeah, maybe it’s a cosmic joke. Maybe we’re all just drifting, trying to make something of nothing. But we still get to decide how we react to the absurdity.

And that’s the last laugh, right?

We may not be in control of everything, but we sure as hell have control over how we face the fight.

And that, my friend, is a glimmer of hope. It’s a small, flickering light in an overwhelmingly dark room.

And maybe that’s enough /but probably not/.

Comments

Leave a Reply